Enterprise Point of Contact:
Michael A. SpottsSenior Policy Analyst
Last Updated: March 29, 2012
Issue Background: Sustainable Communities & Transit-Oriented Development
Sustainable community development refers to planning and building activities that address social equity, environmental stewardship and economic development. This long-term and holistic approach is crucial to the efficient allocation of resources for housing, infrastructure, public transportation and supportive services. Sustainability does not refer to a set of prescriptive development and policy choices. Rather, it is a framework for making decisions that reflect the unique characteristics, challenges and opportunities of a given geographical area. Well-planned development can yield numerous benefits for households, including lower utility and transportation costs, better health outcomes and increased access to employment and other resources. Communities can also benefit from lower infrastructure costs, additional economic development and increased tax revenue.Transit-oriented development (TOD) is an important component of sustainable development. The interrelated costs of housing and transportation are the two largest expenses for many households. Communities closely connected to a broad range of services, retail options and employment opportunities are often associated with higher housing costs. Households can be faced with a choice of paying an unaffordable amount for housing in such communities or living further away and commuting into opportunity-rich areas. In the later scenario, the savings in housing costs can be negated by the increased costs of transportation.
Communities can promote social equity by expanding public transportation access to underserved low- and moderate-income communities and investing in the preservation and/or construction of affordable housing near transit. The preservation of affordable housing is particularly crucial to prevent the displacement and increased cost burden that sometimes result from increases in property values in new transit corridors.
Enterprise supports sustainability through its Enterprise Green Communities initiative and its TOD-related activities. Green Communities provides resources for developers and communities to build well-located green affordable homes. Enterprise’s TOD work includes financing, research and policy advocacy. Enterprise is a lead partner in Mile High Connects, which will create or preserve at least 1,000 affordable homes along current and future transit corridors in the city, and is involved in TOD-financing activities in other cities throughout the country.
Current Policy State
The federal government has a significant impact on the quality of development decisions made by local communities. Fragmented jurisdictions and responsibilities, conflicting regulations and a lack of coordinated can be barriers to local and regional sustainability efforts. Under the Obama Administration, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), Department of Transportation (DOT) and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) established the interagency Partnership for Sustainable Communities (PSC). In addition, HUD established the Office of Sustainable Housing and Communities (OSHC) to implement the Sustainable Communities Initiative (SCI). The PSC and OSHC facilitate inter-agency collaboration and provide funding, capacity building and technical assistance resources that promote the development of sustainable communities that address housing, land use, and transportation needs in a holistic, regionally-focused manner. The PSC, OSHC and SCI have yet to receive formal Congressional authorization and have been operating under the Administration’s discretion. Congress appropriated funding for the SCI in both fiscal years (FY) 2010 and 2011, but did not provide funding in FY 2012. Congress has yet to pass authorization legislation (the Livable Communities Act) for these programs.The Federal Transit Administration’s (FTA) is in the process of revising the rules for its Major Capital Investment Projects program (also known as New Starts/Small Starts). This program is the primary competitive funding source for new federal transit investments. If implemented, the FTA rulemaking would amend the evaluation criteria to measure a wider range of benefits provided by transit projects and streamline the application process. FTA released an advanced notice in 2010 and a proposed rule (49 CFR Part 611; RIN 2132-AB02) and policy guidance (Docket No. FTA-2010-0009) for the program in January 2012. FTA is proposing to assess applicants' plans to develop and preserve affordable housing near new transit stops; encourage intensive development near transit; and promote supportive practices such as green building and improved access to transit stops, among other topics. Enterprise and many partners in the community development field have submitted multiple public comment letters throughout the regulatory process supporting these changes and providing detailed implementation recommendations. For more information, read the complete archive of FTA-related testimony and public comments.
Legislative and Regulatory Priorities
Enterprise supports efforts to harmonize overlapping and conflicting planning regulations and reduce other barriers to regional cooperation, sustainable development, and TOD. Specifically, Enterprise strongly supports the interagency Partnership for Sustainable Communities, Office of Sustainable Housing and Communities and the Sustainable Communities Initiative. To ensure that this work continues, Congress should pass authorizing legislation that ensures that nonprofits and community groups have an opportunity to play an active role in developing and implementing local and regional sustainability plans. Enterprise supports the addition of sustainability criteria into the application scoring process for existing capital and planning funding programs. Finally, Enterprise believes that transportation laws and regulations should provide incentives to coordinate affordable housing and transportation investments, facilitate joint transit and affordable housing development, and provide resources for dedicated funds that support affordable housing and community development near transit.Publications and Resources
Current Sustainable Community Development and TOD-Related Legislation (112th Congress)
- Jumpstarting Transit-Oriented Development Act (S. 2053)
- Livable Communities Act (H.R. 3325 and S. 1621)
- Community Regeneration, Sustainability and Innovation Act (H.R. 790)
- Transit Related Investment Improvement Act (H.R. 3854)
Previous Sustainable Community Development and TOD-Related Legislation (111th Congress)
- Livable Communities Act (S. 1619 and H.R. 4690)
- Enhancing Livability for All American Act of 2009 (H.R. 4287)
- Community Regeneration, Sustainability and Innovation Act of 2009 (S. 453 and H.R. 932)
- Green Resources for Energy Efficient Neighborhoods (GREEN) Act (H.R. 2336) and Energy Efficiency in Housing Act (S. 1379)
Enterprise Resources
- For the latest federal program funding levels, visit the Enterprise Budget and Appropriations webpage.
- Enterprise Green Building, Energy Efficiency and Healthy Homes webpage
- Enterprise Green Communities webpage
- Enterprise Transit-Oriented Development webpage
-
@the Horizon Articles:
- Cars, Busses, Trains and Bikes: How Do You Get to Work?; by Michael Spotts, Policy Analyst, October, 2011
- Connecting Affordable and Workforce Housing to Transit; by Enterprise Board Chairman J. Ronald Terwilliger, June 2011
- Denver Leaders Collaborate to Make TOD Happen; by Bill Sadler, Program Associate at Reconnecting America, June 2011
Enterprise Research and Reports
- Preserving Affordable Housing Near Transit: Case Studies from Atlanta, Denver, Seattle and Washington, D.C. (Full Report and Executive Summary); Enterprise, the National Housing Trust and Reconnecting America, 2010
- Making Affordable Housing at Transit a Reality: Best Practices in Transit Agency Joint Development; Enterprise and FRESC, 2010
- The Case for Mixed-Income Transit-Oriented Development in the Denver Region; Center for Transit-Oriented Development (Commissioned by Enterprise), 2007
Enterprise Statements, Testimony and Public Comment
-
Public Comments to FTA on Coordinating Affordable Housing, Community Development and Public Transportation Investments
- Enterprise comments on New Starts/Small Starts Proposed Rule and Policy Guidance (March 2012)
- Green Affordable Housing Coalition comments on New Starts/Small Starts Proposed Rule and Policy Guidance (March 2012)
- Joint comments on New Starts/Small Starts Policy Guidance from Enterprise, Habitat for Humanity, the Local Initiatives Support Corporation (LISC) and the National Housing Conference (March 2012)
- Joint comments on New Starts/Small Starts Proposed Rule from broad stakeholder coalition (March 2012)
- Enterprise public comments on FTA's Proposed Environmental Justice Circular (December 2011)
- Joint public comments on FTA Regulatory Review (Docket Number: DOT-OST-2011-0025) from Enterprise and the National Housing Conference (April 2011)
- Joint public comment on New Starts/Small Starts Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking from Enterprise, Habitat for Humanity International and the National Housing Conference (August 2010)
-
Additional Sustainable Communities/Transit-Oriented Development-Related Statements, Testimony and Public Comment
- On March 14, 2011 Enterprise Senior Director, Public Policy & Government Affairs Peter Lawrence provided public comment on the application rating factors for the HUD Sustainable Communities Regional Planning Grant program.
- March 10, 2010, Vice President, Public Policy and Government Relations Adrienne Quinn provided comments on the Sustainable Communities Planning Grant Advance Notice and Request for Comments
- On July 28, Vice President, Public Policy and Government Relations Adrienne Quinn provided a letter of support for the Livable Communities Act (S. 1619) in advance of the August 3 Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee markup.
HUD Sustainable Communities Initiative Funding
External Resources
- Bay Area Transit-Oriented Affordable Housing Fund
- Center for Neighborhood Technology
- Center for Transit-Oriented Development (CTOD)
- Environmental Protection Agency Smart Growth webpage
- Federal Transit Administration (FTA)
- HUD Office of Sustainable Housing and Communities
- Local Initiatives Support Corporation
- Low Income Investment Fund
- Mixed-Income Transit-Oriented Development National Action Guide (developed by Reconnecting America and CTOD and sponsored by the FTA)
- National Housing Conference (NHC) and the Center for Housing Policy (CHP)
- National Housing Trust
- Partnership for Sustainable Communities
- PolicyLink
- Reconnecting America
- Smart Growth America
- Transportation for America
External Research and Reports
- Local, Regional and State Policy Options to Support Sustainable and Equitable Development, CHP, 2011
- Challenges and Policy Options for Creating and Preserving Affordable Housing near Transit and in Other Location-Efficient Areas, CHP and NHC, 2011
- Community Development Financial Institutions and Transit-Oriented Development; prepared by CTOD and Strategic Economics for the Low Income Investment Fund, 2010
- Maintaining Diversity in America’s Transit-Rich Neighborhoods; Dukakis Center for Urban and Regional Policy at Northeastern University, 2010
- Affordable Housing in Transit-Oriented Development: Key Practices Could Enhance Recent Collaboration Efforts between DOT-FTA and HUD; Government Accountability Office (GAO), 2009
